First of all, I conclude that I write too much. Really.
CASL is a completely different subject, and as you know, very controversial in industry. On the other hand, the Office of the Privacy Commissioner has issued its first investigation into CASL this summer, and I believe that consumers will be happy to see the restrictions that have been put on industry.
To answer your question of whether it hits the right balance, I would suggest we wait a few more years. What I mean by that is that we should accumulate more experience on how business feels that it responds to a genuine desire for promotional ads or information and their own needs.
There is consent. You can obtain the right to get promotional information, and in fact the comparison that Mr. Saini made a moment ago about opting in and opting out, this is under the Privacy Act but is an architecture of control that can allow the sending of promotional—therefore commercial—economic messages to a consenting recipient and to make a definition that you want everything or you don't want everything. There we can find a proper balance between the rights of the consumer not to be bombarded, as you say, and the needs or the desire of the organization to help its marketing initiatives through that.